WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
- Bladerunner808
- Senior Angler
- Posts: 174
- Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 4:29 pm
WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
Just a lightweight question here... It seems like the swimbait label is applied to WAY too many lures. 5" skinny dippers (greatest lure ever) are a soft plastic to me. A jointed Rapala? It seems by todays standards that would also have to qualify that as a swimbait. I think that the term swimbait (as a "Tackle Warehouse" term) should mean hard bodied, or soft bodied (Hudd style) - realistic lures 6" or greater. Its strange that we refer to a sub 5" spro shad as a swimbait. No?
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
I tend to use the terms "big bait" for 5", 1oz baits and bigger. When it is a big topwater, I use the term "mag topwater". I also use the term "paddletail" to refer to Basstrix and Fat Impact type baits.
"Swimbait" is just a bait that "swims", IMO. A 3" Keitech Fat Impact is technically a swimbait...so is a Mister Twister Sassy Shad...and so is a Mattlures Dead Twitch. If a Giron is not a swimbait, what is it?
My 2 cents...
"Swimbait" is just a bait that "swims", IMO. A 3" Keitech Fat Impact is technically a swimbait...so is a Mister Twister Sassy Shad...and so is a Mattlures Dead Twitch. If a Giron is not a swimbait, what is it?
My 2 cents...
- Bladerunner808
- Senior Angler
- Posts: 174
- Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2013 4:29 pm
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
Yeah, its weird. I guess I've been using swimbaits since the early 80's...
- angry john
- Platinum Angler
- Posts: 1108
- Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2012 7:16 pm
- Location: Millington TN.
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
I call anything larger than or equal to 6" a swim bait. There is tons of grey area, and marketing is always trying to get the new bait to fit into the latest class. Is a keitech swing impact a swimbait? I try not to split hairs, and if you want to call something a swimbait, far be it from me to call you wrong. If your swimming a curly tail grub is that a swimbait.
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
There are big (7") rubber minnow baits from the late 1800's. Some SoCal guys think they "pioneered" big baits.Bladerunner808 wrote:Yeah, its weird. I guess I've been using swimbaits since the early 80's...
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
Those "pioneers" were crossover guys that took their Calico bass gear, specifically Worm Kings and started throwing them for green bass. Worm King then decided to make the Dinosaur, which was a larger bait they poured in rainbow trout, then came guys like Alan Cole. Also, most of these guys transfered their longer jig sticks that had been wrapped as saltwater bass rods over to throwing swimbaits. Makes me laugh every time a musky guy says they deserve credit for swimbaits and how we fish out here.Tokugawa wrote:There are big (7") rubber minnow baits from the late 1800's. Some SoCal guys think they "pioneered" big baits.Bladerunner808 wrote:Yeah, its weird. I guess I've been using swimbaits since the early 80's...
As far as drawing the line, I agree, there is a lot of gray area with what a swimbait really is.
- Reel Old Geezer
- TT Gear Crew
- Posts: 1287
- Joined: Wed Jan 05, 2005 11:19 am
- Location: So Shore of Lake Lowell
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
Tokugawa is correct. Everything cycles and Nothin's New. Those Californians might have thought they were doing something original, but... Henshall wrote about what today we call swimbaits in his BOOK OF THE BLACK BASS in 1881. And every generation or two since those days someone has "pioneered" using musky baits for bass fishing. Take a look at a Heddon Musky Vamp, or many other plugs from the 1920s and 1930s. Today, fishing is all about marketing, and swimbaits and accompanying rods and reels were a great market for tackle manufacturers.bigswaim wrote:Those "pioneers" were crossover guys that took their Calico bass gear, specifically Worm Kings and started throwing them for green bass. Worm King then decided to make the Dinosaur, which was a larger bait they poured in rainbow trout, then came guys like Alan Cole. Also, most of these guys transfered their longer jig sticks that had been wrapped as saltwater bass rods over to throwing swimbaits. Makes me laugh every time a musky guy says they deserve credit for swimbaits and how we fish out here.Tokugawa wrote:There are big (7") rubber minnow baits from the late 1800's. Some SoCal guys think they "pioneered" big baits.Bladerunner808 wrote:Yeah, its weird. I guess I've been using swimbaits since the early 80's...
As far as drawing the line, I agree, there is a lot of gray area with what a swimbait really is.
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
If I have to pull out the 867 or bypassers think I just caught something nice than its a Swimbait.
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
Here's a nice article:
http://bassfishingarchives.com/western/ ... e-swimbait
The rest of the site is good too. There's an article Bill Murphy wrote about worms that's hosted there. Can't find it right now, but I'll be happy to email it to anyone who wants it (saved it as a pdf when I found it.)
P.S. George Perry's bass was caught on a swimbait too.
http://bassfishingarchives.com/western/ ... e-swimbait
The rest of the site is good too. There's an article Bill Murphy wrote about worms that's hosted there. Can't find it right now, but I'll be happy to email it to anyone who wants it (saved it as a pdf when I found it.)
P.S. George Perry's bass was caught on a swimbait too.
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
It is something you have showed me over and over again ROG. Once I started to just peek into the Pflueger roots of Akron, OH, I found a world of interesting things. We all truly stand on the shoulders of giants.Reel Old Geezer wrote:Tokugawa is correct. Everything cycles and Nothin's New. Those Californians might have thought they were doing something original, but... Henshall wrote about what today we call swimbaits in his BOOK OF THE BLACK BASS in 1881. And every generation or two since those days someone has "pioneered" using musky baits for bass fishing. Take a look at a Heddon Musky Vamp, or many other plugs from the 1920s and 1930s. Today, fishing is all about marketing, and swimbaits and accompanying rods and reels were a great market for tackle manufacturers.
Don't get me wrong, the SoCal guys certainly added their flair, ingenuity and take on things. Perhaps they coined the "swimbait" nomenclature. They also had the technology/materials to make more efficient and optimized sticks. They just weren't the first.
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
No - that's a grub.angry john wrote:If your swimming a curly tail grub is that a swimbait.
In my feeble mind, it must have a fishy profile and have a boot tail or hinges/joints to create a swimming motion. But then, some people consider a Lunker Punker a "swimbait", and it has neither a boot tail nor joints. To make matters worse, arbitrary size gets used as a criteria, so a 8" LP is a "swimbait" (without a joint to boot tail) as is a 6", but a 5" LP is not.
Stop the madness!
- angry john
- Platinum Angler
- Posts: 1108
- Joined: Mon Jan 16, 2012 7:16 pm
- Location: Millington TN.
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
Your right I was just being an a## only to show I don't judge.Tokugawa wrote:No - that's a grub.angry john wrote:If your swimming a curly tail grub is that a swimbait.
In my feeble mind, it must have a fishy profile and have a boot tail or hinges/joints to create a swimming motion. But then, some people consider a Lunker Punker a "swimbait", and it has neither a boot tail nor joints. To make matters worse, arbitrary size gets used as a criteria, so a 8" LP is a "swimbait" (without a joint to boot tail) as is a 6", but a 5" LP is not.
Stop the madness!
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
I agree. If it isn't thrown on a swimbait rod {at least a heavy } it isn't a swimbait. Or if people aren't laughing at you when they see you throwing it, it isn't a swimbait.GARRIGA wrote:If I have to pull out the 867 or bypassers think I just caught something nice than its a Swimbait.
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
It's easier to laugh at most baits in some parts of the country, vs REEEELY BEEG BASS COUNTRY!johns wrote:I agree. If it isn't thrown on a swimbait rod {at least a heavy } it isn't a swimbait. Or if people aren't laughing at you when they see you throwing it, it isn't a swimbait.GARRIGA wrote:If I have to pull out the 867 or bypassers think I just caught something nice than its a Swimbait.
-
- Senior Angler
- Posts: 106
- Joined: Tue Dec 18, 2007 2:46 am
- Location: Nor-Cal
Re: WHERE do you draw the swimbait line?
A swimbait to me is not so much the style of bait. To me it is a bait that catches Big fish and limits that we dream of or even better. When they came out they were to catch "trophy fish", period. To me once you get under 6" I would just use a Crank bait/ Jig or somthing like that because your target size fish is not going to be as big. Sure you will get a good one here and there, you can with a Jig too. But to Target trophy or the Bigger fish , 8"+ baits are best for me to get that done. Some seem to just want more bites or fish, I don't see why some of those people even bother with swimbaits if that's what they are looking for. Even though an A rig has smaller baits and catches a wide range of fish it is in fact an A rig not a swimbait, to me. I don't use them anyway, one DD at a time is plenty for me
I guess it really doesn't matter as long as you are having fun, call them what you want.
I guess it really doesn't matter as long as you are having fun, call them what you want.